We have long been warning about owning real estate that need flood insurance. The fact of the matter is global warming is causing the sea level to rise, as well as, extreme weather events.
Now, the Wall Street Journal has joined the chorus:
By
SIOBHAN HUGHES
A new law meant to stabilize the federal government’s money-losing flood-insurance program is starting to send rates sky high, prompting a growing backlash in coastal areas.
The Biggert-Waters law, enacted in 2012 before superstorm Sandy hit the Eastern Seaboard, requires that government insurance premiums for the 5.6 million property owners in flood-prone regions be set at a level that better reflects the full risk of flooding. It was prompted by cumulative losses that had ballooned to $24 billion for the National Flood Insurance Program.
The changes mean some owners must retrofit their homes or businesses—by raising buildings higher above the ground and taking other measures—to better guard against flooding, or pay rates that could surge to $10,000 and higher a year.
Property owners along the Gulf Coast and Eastern Seaboard, used to annual premiums of about $1,000, are starting to feel the impact.
Vacation homes are subject to new insurance rates starting this year, while primary residences already subject to flood insurance will get new rates in phases.
The government also is redrawing flood-zone maps that will classify more properties as flood risks.
Bill Bubrig, a 47-year-old insurance agent in Plaquemines Parish, La., is at the leading edge of the sticker shock.
“This will be much worse than Hurricane Katrina as far as the devastation that it’s going to cause the lower end of our parish,” he said.
Mr. Bubrig estimated that flood-insurance premiums on his home will increase from $633 to $28,000 a year, with a big chunk of the increase hitting as early as 2014.
For Mr. Bubrig, who 15 years ago built his home two feet above the minimum elevation, part of the problem is a pending new flood map that says his home is actually six feet too low. The flood-insurance law compels him to undertake expensive improvements or pay higher premiums.
Because of the new law, a previously available exemption that applies to homes that were built to code also is no longer available. Mr. Bubrig said his home has never flooded.
To soften the impact, some members of Congress are asking the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which administers the federal flood insurance program, to delay implementing parts of the law while lawmakers consider changes to limit premium increases.
Louisiana’s two senators, Mary Landrieu, a Democrat, and David Vitter, a Republican, in late July threatened to hold up the possible nomination of FEMA Administrator Craig Fugate as Department of Homeland Security secretary—should the White House decide to nominate him for a post being vacated by Janet Napolitano—unless FEMA makes changes to the insurance program.
“We both feel strongly that these challenges must be addressed in a very serious manner before he is promoted to any other position,” the lawmakers said in a July 29 letter to President Barack Obama.
FEMA is an agency within DHS. The White House, through a spokesman, declined to comment.
The issue has transcended partisan lines, despite opposition from some conservatives who want to end federal flood insurance altogether. A third of the fiscally conservative Republican Study Committee joined Democrats in a June House vote to back the delay.
“You literally would be forcing those people out of their homes,” said Rep. Steve Scalise (R., La.), the head of the RSC.
Two groups of property owners accustomed to government-subsidized insurance are feeling the effect the most: Those who own properties built before the release of the first federal flood maps, which outline flood zones, and owners of grandfathered properties that either met flood guidelines when they were built or have since been determined to lie in flood-prone areas.
Opting out isn’t a choice for many, since flood insurance is mandatory for properties with federally insured mortgages. And there is little people can do to lower premiums shy of elevating properties, which likely would cost multiple tens of thousands of dollars.
A FEMA spokesman said the agency is simply focused on implementing the law, and said that while some rates may rise, others may fall. “FEMA is in the process of implementing the law as directed by Congress,” FEMA spokesman Dan Watson said.
“In the long run, it will be important for the NFIP to ultimately implement these measures in order to achieve fiscal soundness and long-term stability,” said Willem Rijksen, a spokesman for the American Insurance Association.
The new insurance rules are also playing out in areas hit by superstorm Sandy last fall.
The number of buildings in New York City’s flood zone is expected to double, to about 67,700, based on flood maps that are under development using data compiled by the city and provided by FEMA.
Jake Beinecke, who bought a 19th century home in the Red Hook section of Brooklyn last year, shortly after the law was passed, is trying to figure out his options, none of which he said seem ideal.
Mr. Beinecke’s home flooded during Sandy, causing nearly $90,000 of damage that was only partially covered by the flood-insurance program.
Since then, he and his partner have given up a below-grade ground floor, forcing them to stop renting an apartment unit they hoped would help cover a portion of the mortgage, and relocating the boiler and other utilities to a higher floor to limit damage from future floods.
But he said FEMA won’t give him credit for all the changes, threatening to leave him with premiums he expects to run between $9,000 and $12,000 a year.
FEMA says that it does give credit for renovations to limit flood damage, but people are sometimes disappointed when the savings don’t add up.
“The only solution I see is some sort of political conversation that needs to take place that hasn’t taken place yet,” said Mary Delaney Krugman, a historic-preservation specialist whose second home, a cottage in Ocean City, N.J., flooded during Sandy.
RELATED ARTICLES:
-
Flood Insurance Program of FEMA for residential mortgages and …
membrane.com/allrealestate/flood_insurance.htmlArticle and interactive study on floodplain maps, floodplain, FEMA, and flood insurance for homes in high-risk areas, as well as, random acts of nature. Originally …
Should Coastal Communities Be Rebuilt – World Citizen Network
worldcitizen.net/green/should-coastal-communities-be-rebuilt/7 days ago – Since flood insurance is a government program, advocates suggest FEMA not offer insurance to coastal communities. This entry was posted in …
WorldCitizen.net | Environmental Issues, Ecology, Energy, Climate …
worldcitizen.net/green/2010/2010-03-16.htmlMar 11, 2010 – •Captive and free-ranging Insurance Populations •Collaborative …. FEMA and NOAA Renew Partnership to Encourage Flood Safety. As one of …
-
Flood Insurance Reform / Global Warming / Climate Change
orpheus.membrane.com/enterhtml/live/…/flood_insurance/reform.html“The NFIP was created because of the lack of available and affordable flood insurance in the private market, which remains true today, and serves as an …
-
New Temple University Floodplain Maps, FEMA, Flood Insurance …
membrane.com/global_warming/notes/Temple_Floodplain_Maps.htmlPosted on Sun, Oct. 01, 2006. Floodplain maps force towns into tricky waters. Temple urged its data over FEMA’s. Choosing either will hurt someone. By Diane
… -
Flood Insurance — Who pays for flood insurance? Does your …
2008.membrane.com/widgette.com/flood_insurance/Free information about the costs and benefits of flood insurance on residential and commerical real estate.
-
Who Pays For Flood Insurance?
2008.membrane.com/widgette.com/flood_insurance/Who_Pays.htmlSep 25, 2006 – Flood insurance for homeowners is required to obtain most mortgages for homes located in floodplain maps’ flooding zones.
-
Flood Insurance Program of FEMA for residential mortgages and …
membrane.com/x…/0…/flood_insurance_espanol.htmlTranslate this pageSeguro De Inundación. El seminario hecho porla agencia de viviendas de Finanzas de Pennsylvania fue absolutamente un éxito. El Tema era el programa
… -
Membrane.com | Everything at the Membrane Domain
membrane.com/current-events/2013/2013-05-31-15.htmlMay 31, 2013 – What is flood insurance? http://membrane.com/allrealestate/flood_insurance.
htmlFlood Insurance Program of FEMA for residential mortgages … -
Early 2007 saw record-breaking extreme weather: U.N.
membrane.com/global_warming/notes/extreme_weather.htmlEarly 2007 Saw Record-breaking Extreme Weather: U.N.. By Laura MacInnis Tue Aug 7, 8:40 AM ET. GENEVA (Reuters) – The world experienced a series of …
-
Severe Weather The New Normal – Membrane.com
everything.membrane.com/severe-weather-the-new-normal/Jan 14, 2013 – One of the most significant costs is the impact of more severe weather events. A LETTER TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. Climate change, once …
-
Membrane.com | Everything at the Membrane Domain
membrane.com/current-events/2013/2013-06-14-15.htmlJun 14, 2013 – Why are there more extreme weather events? … One of the most significant costs is the impact of more severe weather events. […] …
-
Global Warming, Climate Change & Population Study Research
membrane.com/global_warming/notes/climate_change.html“We may already be seeing – in the increased incidence of drought, floods and extreme weather events that many regions are experiencing – some of the …
-
Global Warming: Damage Caused by Greenhouse Gases and the …
membrane.com/global_warming/resources.htmlNow, as the effects of extreme weather and rising oceans hit communities from the Philippines to New Jersey, the UN has realized it must begin to grapple with …
-
Human Induced
idea.membrane.com/songwriter/2013/06/26/human-induced/Jun 26, 2013 – This song was inspired by more extreme weather events. Find out more about human induced climate change and global warming.
-
Coastal Change: Hurricanes and Extreme Storm Hazards
everything.membrane.com/coastal-change-hurricanes-and-extreme-stor…May 8, 2013 – Coastal Change: Hurricanes and Extreme Storm Hazards … Global Warming, Science, weather and tagged climate change, coastal change, …
-
Who Pays For Flood Insurance? – All Real Estate
allrealestate.com/for-sale/who-pays-for-flood-insurance/Feb 24, 2010 – What government insurance plans are subsidized by the taxpayers and available to everyone? Probably, the only answer is flood insurance.
-
Flood Insurance Reform | AllRealEstate: Real Estate For Sale News
allrealestate.com/for-sale/flood-insurance-reform/Oct 8, 2011 – The National Association of Realtors® is pleased that a continuing resolution passed by Congress today included a short-term extension of the …
-
National Flood Insurance | AllRealEstate: Real Estate For Sale News
allrealestate.com/for-sale/national-flood-insurance/Mar 16, 2010 – Madison, Wisconsin — The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) had its roots in the 1800s as the country recognized the federal …
-
Action On Flood Insurance Renewal – All Real Estate
allrealestate.com/for-sale/action-on-flood-insurance-renewal/Apr 7, 2010 – The National Association of Realtors® said today that it will continue to press Congress for speedy action to renew authority for the Federal …
-
Flood Protection And Insurance – All Real Estate
allrealestate.com/for-sale/flood-protection-and-insurance/Mar 15, 2010 – Did you know that you have to purchase flood insurance seperately from your homeowner’s insurance policy? * Did you know flood insurance …
-
National Flood Insurance Program Borrowing Authority
sale.allrealestate.com/…/national-flood-insurance-program-borrowing-au…Jan 3, 2013 – WASHINGTON – The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), mandated by Congress to administer the National Flood Insurance …
-
New Flood Plain Maps For Washington, DC – All Real Estate
allrealestate.com/for-sale/new-flood-plain-maps-for-washington-dc/Mar 27, 2010 – DENTON, Texas — Chester, Texas is now a participating community in the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) and that means those …
-
3 – All Real Estate
allrealestate.com/for-sale/page/3/DENTON, Texas — Chester, Texas is now a participating community in the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) and that means those living and working in …
-
National Flood Insurance – All Real Estate
allrealestate.com/markets/2010-04-08.htmlApr 8, 2010 – NAR to Press Congress for Immediate Action on Flood Insurance … Agency to issue flood insurance under the National Flood Insurance …
-
-